An American Pickle

Seth Rogen

As Herschel Greenbaum / Ben Greenbaum

Sarah Snook

As Sarah Greenbaum

Molly Evensen

As Clara

Eliot Glazer

As Christian

Kalen Allen

As Kevin

Kevin O'Rourke

As Dane Brunt

Sean Whalen

As Scientist

Geoffrey Cantor

As David Greenbaum

Carol Leifer

As Susan Greenbaum

Jorma Taccone

As Liam

Marsha Stephanie Blake

As Inspector Sanders

Alyse Zwick

As News Anchor

Dalon Huntington

As Border Patrol Agent

Jeremy Michael Grey

As Border Patrol Agent

Efka Kvaraciejus

As Fish Monger

Darryl Bailey Smith II

As Teenage Drone Operator

Dino Rende

As Teenage Kid

Peter Kybart

As Old Man

Joanna Adler

As Professor Kim Ecklund

Herb Mendelsohn

As Rabbi

Norm Golden

As Wedding Rabbi

Al Nazemian

As Cab Driver

Adam Dunhoff

As Congregant

Mark Diamond

As Congregant

Leib Cohen

As Congregant

Liz Cackowski

As Susan O'Malley

Tim Robinson

As Prosecuting Attorney

Betsy Sodaro

As Defense Attorney

Quinta Brunson

As Female Interviewee

Kurt Braunohler

As Male Interviewee

Michael Weaver

As Judge

David Flick

As Construction Worker

Raymond Neil Hernandez

As Officer Kadushin

John Walpole

As Seltzer Man

Ian Poake

As Devon

Charles Rogers

As Ellis Island Officer

Jess Stark

As Female Cashier

Jon Donahue

As Local Reporter

Amy Marsalis

As Reporter

Paul Monte Jr.

As Second Reporter

Julie Mun

As Third Reporter

Allan Snyder

As Moderator

Fabio Polanco

As Audience Member

Havilah Brewster

As Second Audience Member

Francis Capone

As Manager

Alex McAtee

As Bartender

Dionysius Akeem

As Cliff

Nick Arapoglou

As Todd (uncredited)

Paul Castro Jr.

As Freegan (uncredited)

Alexandre Chen

As Chinese Worker (uncredited)

Kristin Cochell

As Nika (uncredited)

Chuck Filipov

As Schlupsk Man (uncredited)

David Mattey

As Ivan (uncredited)

Jeff Daniel Phillips

As Actor (uncredited)

Adam Ratcliffe

As ICE Agent (uncredited)

Estes Tarver

As ICE Agent (uncredited)

Lou Consolo

As Man Walking in Park (uncredited)