The Baby-Sitters Club

Schuyler Fisk

As Kristy

Bre Blair

As Stacey

Rachael Leigh Cook

As Mary Anne

Larisa Oleynik

As Dawn

Tricia Joe

As Claudia

Stacy Linn Ramsower

As Mallory

Zelda Harris

As Jessi

Vanessa Zima

As Rosie Wilder

Christian Oliver

As Luca

Brooke Adams

As Elizabeth Thomas Brewer

Bruce Davison

As Watson

Jessica Needham

As Karen

Ellen Burstyn

As Mrs. Haberman

Asher Metchik

As Jackie Rodowsky

Austin O'Brien

As Logan Bruno

Marla Sokoloff

As Cokie Mason

Ashlee Turner

As Bebe

Natanya Ross

As Grace

Katie Earle

As Nina Marshall

Scarlett Pomers

As Suzi Barrett

Kyla Pratt

As Becca

Annie Costner

As Annie

Lily Costner

As Lily

David Quittman

As Buddy Barrett

Jonah Bliss

As Nicky

Josh Berman

As Ricky

Emmy Yu

As Emmy / Camper

E.J. De la Pena

As Jonas

Madison Fisk

As Beth

Cleo Brock-Abraham

As Cleo

Lance O'Reilly

As Matt

Bridget Kate Geraghty

As Vanessa

Erica Hess

As Margie Klinger

Samantha Alanis

As Charlotte Johanssen

Aaron Michael Metchik

As Alan

Peter Horton

As Patrick

Jeffrey Quittman

As Jamie Newton

Colleen Camp

As Maureen McGill

Teddy Dale

As David Michael

Robin Swid

As Brookes

Richard Guiton

As Mark

Peter Gregory

As Bouncer

Candy Trabuco

As Cabbie

Harris Yulin

As Harold

Aixa Clemente

As Louise

Nancy Mette

As Sheila

Melanie Mayron

As Waitress (uncredited)