Stolen

Jon Hamm

As Tom Adkins Sr.

Josh Lucas

As Matthew Wakefield

Rhona Mitra

As Barbara

James Van Der Beek

As Diploma / Roggiani

Jessica Chastain

As Sally Ann

Joanna Cassidy

As Lea Adkins

Jimmy Bennett

As John

Morena Baccarin

As Rose Montgomery

Michael Cudlitz

As Jonas

Beth Grant

As Older Edvena

Holt McCallany

As Swede

Andy Milder

As William Daniels

Jude Ciccolella

As Police Chief

Rick Gomez

As Officer JJ

Marcus Thomas

As Pete Dunne

Graham Phillips

As Mark Wakefield

Kali Rocha

As Coral

Sam Hennings

As Older Luke Wakefield

Tom Kemp

As Russell MacArthur

Benjamin Burdick

As George Montgomery

Kim Hamilton

As Miz Betsy

Bob Stephenson

As Mike the Bartender

William Charles Mitchell

As Lou

Glenn Taranto

As Chollie

Ryan Cutrona

As Bill Byrnes

Ty Panitz

As Tommy Jr.

Ray Proscia

As Lawyer

Elizabeth Small

As Edvena

Enuka Okuma

As Officer Angie Riddick

Angela Schnaible

As Girl

Jeanette Brox

As Lisa

Kasey Campbell

As Micha

Cheyenne Wilbur

As Old Minister

Pamela Dunlap

As Shelly the Waitress

Rutanya Alda

As Older Sally Ann

James Mathers

As Joel Schubert

Paul Keith

As Barber

Jonathan Erickson Eisley

As Mick

Channing Chase

As Lorraine

Charles C. Stevenson Jr.

As Man Getting a Cut

Bart McCarthy

As Kevin Byrnes

Tonye Patano

As Elsie Mauer

Beresford Bennett

As Investigator

Al Corley

As Uncle Sam