
Will a mysterious stranger's past wreak havoc on a quiet Amish community after they've opened their doors -- and hearts -- to him and his son?

Made in US
6.5/10
2014
Server
Having issues? Try switching to a different server.
Cast

Tom Everett Scott
As Joe Matthews / Micah Matthias

Sarah Lancaster
As Rachel Troyler

Thomas Kapanowski
As Bobby Matthews / Bobby Matthias

Kelly McGillis
As Bertha Troyler

Nicole Badaan
As Kim

Annie Kitral
As Lydia Troyler
Katherine DeBoer
As Chloe Styles
Marianna Alacchi
As Anna Troyler

Ken Strunk
As Eli Troyler

Greg Violand
As Ed Spencer
John Eby
As Sam Phillips
Geoffrey Hoffman
As Dylan Matthias
Kaitlyn Sapp
As Elise
Chris Van Vliet
As Reporter #1
Jeannie Madison
As Reporter #2
Madison Blake
As Ypung Rachel Troyler
Dave McConnell
As Frank Troyer

Joe Kurak
As Head Official
Dave Durch
As Disheveled Guy
Kyle Primous
As Mechanic

Serena Miller
As Cashier
Kris Leiter
As Umpire

Mary Anne Prevost
As Mary Anne (Bank Teller)
Trenton Huff
As Bobby Double
Abe M. Yoder
As Horse & Buggy Wrangler
Nicole Miller
As Horse Trainer
Blaze
As Buggy Horse
Curtis Blackburn
As Amish Youths Chasing Buggy
Jason Burroughs
As Amish Youths Chasing Buggy
Ryan Schultz
As Grungy Guy
Kirk Putman
As Garaway Baseball Team
Michah VanFossen
As Garaway Baseball Team

Brandon Weaver
As Garaway Baseball Team
B.J. Schwartz
As Garaway Baseball Team
Benjamin Mason
As Garaway Baseball Team
Brandon Johnson
As Garaway Baseball Team
Zach Huffman
As Garaway Baseball Team
Tyrrell Keim
As Garaway Baseball Team
Jerrod F. Hunt
As Garaway Baseball Team
Joe Haynes
As Garaway Baseball Team
Seth Miller
As Garaway Baseball Team
Parker Barnhouse
As Garaway Baseball Team
More
Love Finds You in Charm
TalhotBlond
Miss Marple: They Do It with Mirrors
Aurora Teagarden Mysteries: A Very Foul Play
Garage Sale Mystery: A Case Of Murder
Aurora Teagarden Mysteries: Reunited and It Feels So Deadly
Three Bedrooms, One Corpse: An Aurora Teagarden Mystery
Normal
Gourmet Detective: A Healthy Place to Die
My Dinner with Hervé
Freshman Father
Jacob
Brand Upon the Brain!
Crossword Mysteries: Abracadaver
Starving in Suburbia
Aurora Teagarden Mysteries: Til Death Do Us Part
Mystery 101: Playing Dead
Come Sunday
Wedding Planner Mystery
Crossword Mysteries: Riddle Me Dead
Love's Sweet Recipe
The Way to the Heart
A Dash of Love
An Uncommon Grace
Hazel's People
Expecting Amish
All Summer Long
Love on the Road
Love's Last Resort
Baked with a Kiss
Violent Saturday
Seasoned With Love
Recipe for Love
Blinding Light
Sun, Sand & Romance
Amish Abduction
Art of Falling in Love
The Frisco Kid
Looking for Mr. Right
Love at the Shore