Mickey Blue Eyes

Hugh Grant

As Michael Felgate

James Caan

As Frank Vitale

Jeanne Tripplehorn

As Gina Vitale

Burt Young

As Vito Graziosi

James Fox

As Philip Cromwell

Joe Viterelli

As Vinnie D'Agostino

Gerry Becker

As FBI Agent Bob Connell

Maddie Corman

As Carol the Photographer

Tony Darrow

As Angel

Paul Lazar

As Ritchie Vitale

Vincent Pastore

As Al

Lorri Bagley

As Antoinette

Scott Thompson

As FBI Agent Lewis

John Ventimiglia

As Johnny Graziosi

Frank Pellegrino

As Sante

Marsha Dietlein

As Proposed Girl in Restaurant

John Di Benedetto

As Harold Green

Mark Margolis

As Gene Morgansen

Joseph R. Gannascoli

As Jimmy, Gina's Doorman

Frank Senger

As Delivery Driver

Lori Tan Chinn

As Chinese Restaurant Owner

John DiResta

As Traffic Cop

Melissa Marsala

As Carla, Johnny's Girlfriend

Margaret Devine

As Helen, Michael's Assistant

Beatrice Winde

As Mrs. Horton, Michael's Neighbor

Helen Lloyd Breed

As Elderly Auction Bidder Lady

Carmine Parisi

As Goon in Freezer

Sybil Lines

As Caroline Cromwell

Alexis Brentani

As Bridesmaid

Rose Caiola

As Bridesmaid

Felicia Scarangello

As Bridesmaid

Rocco Musacchia

As Carmine

Bruno Gunn

As Technician

Richard Topol

As FBI Chef in Truck

Steve Mellor

As FBI Chef Leader

Ephraim Benton

As Student

Ed Wheeler

As Reporter

Aida Turturro

As Italian Waitress

Tony Sirico

As First Risolli Man

Brian Davies

As Priest

Joseph Rigano

As Tony Risolli

Michael Kennealy

As Jeffrey

Leonardo Sessa

As FBI Chef

Andy Redmond

As FBI Chef

Chris McGinn

As Tourist Woman

David McConeghey

As Tourist Man

Stephen Dym

As Cromwell Employee

Shelagh Ratner

As Art Patron

Tom King

As Art Patron

Kevin Kean Murphy

As Auction Bidder

Sara Colton

As Nora

Barbara Christie

As Michael's Wedding Guest (uncredited)

Denise George

As Student (uncredited)

Lisa Lang

As Student (uncredited)

Richard D'Alessandro

As Patron at chinese restaurant (uncredited)

Al Cerullo

As Helicopter Pilot (uncredited)